Skip to content
Marlbridge

AP® English Literature and Composition · Unit 1 · Topic 1.5

Writing a Paragraph With a Claim and Textual Evidence: Revision Notes (English Literature 1.5)

A one-page recap of the claim-and-evidence paragraph: what makes a claim, how to choose and embed evidence, tense and accuracy, common mistakes and a quick self-check.

Recap

A literary-analysis paragraph begins with a claim (a statement about the text that needs defence) and textual evidence (specific details or short, exact quotations). A link sentence explains how the evidence supports the claim. Quotations are embedded in your own sentence and the present tense is used for what the text does.

Key relationships

Part What it is Test
Claim A statement that needs defence with evidence Could a reasonable reader ask “how do you know?”
Evidence Specific details or short quotations Is it exact, relevant and specific?
Link A sentence explaining how the evidence supports the claim Does it say how, not just place the quotation?
Fact A statement that needs no defence Not a claim
Summary A retelling of events Not a claim, not evidence

What you may assume

  • The reader of your paragraph has read the text, so you do not need to retell it.
  • You may paraphrase when exact words are not needed, but a claim should rest on details that the text contains.
  • An interpretation can begin from a claim and then find evidence, or begin from details and then form a claim.

Mistakes to avoid

  • Opening with a fact or with a summary.
  • Using a trait word (“nice”, “bad”) as the claim.
  • Quoting a long block instead of the words you need.
  • Changing a quotation, or quoting from memory.
  • Mixing past and present tense when writing about the text.

Key terms

  • Claim: a statement about the text that requires defence with evidence.
  • Evidence: specific details or short, exact quotations from the text.
  • Link: a sentence explaining how the evidence supports the claim.
  • Embedded quotation: a quotation built into the grammar of your own sentence.

Sentence frames

  • “[Character / narrator / speaker] [verb] … , which suggests that ….”
  • “The phrase ‘…’ shows … because ….”
  • “Taken together, these details show ….”

Mini-example

Weak: “Ilse is sad.” Better: “Ilse’s habit of standing at the jetty ‘for the full length of the old crossing’ shows that she cannot accept that the ferry has ended.”

How questions ask about this

  • “Which of the following is a claim?”: choose the statement that needs defence, not a fact or summary.
  • “Which evidence best supports the claim?”: choose the detail that bears most directly on it.
  • “Which sentence best embeds the quotation?”: look for exact words, grammar that fits and a link.
  • Constructed response: open with a claim, add two accurate quotations, and write a link sentence.

Quick self-check

  1. Is “The story is set in a market” a claim? Why or why not?
  2. Embed “the far end where the cobbles gave way to mud” in a sentence about Sandeep.
  3. What does a link sentence do?

Answers.

  1. No. It states a fact that needs no defence. A claim would say what the setting conveys.
  2. For example: Sandeep is placed at “the far end where the cobbles gave way to mud”, which marks him as an outsider.
  3. It explains how the evidence supports the claim, so the reader sees the reasoning, not only the quotation.

Full explanations are in the study guide. Try the practice questions next.

AP® and Advanced Placement® are trademarks registered by the College Board, which is not affiliated with, and does not endorse, this website. Marlbridge is an independent tuition provider. It is not an authorized AP course provider, an AP school or an exam centre, and these resources are not official College Board materials. Reading them or doing simulations does not meet the laboratory requirement of an AP science course.