Skip to content
Marlbridge

AP® English Literature and Composition · Unit 9 · Topic 9.6

Thesis and commentary in a literary argument essay: Topic Checklist (English Literature 9.6)

Specific "I can" statements for thesis and commentary in a literary argument essay, each linked to the guide section and practice question that tests it.

Work through the list without notes. If you cannot do a statement, follow its link, then come back. Guide = study guide; Practice = practice questions.

Understanding

  • I can explain what the literary argument prompt asks, and why the claim must be about the whole work. (Guide: “What the literary argument essay asks of you”)
  • I can explain what a defensible thesis is for a whole-work argument and why a restatement or a plot summary does not count. (Guide: “A defensible thesis about a whole work”; Practice Question 1)
  • I can explain what a line of reasoning is. (Guide: “From thesis to line of reasoning”; Practice Question 2)
  • I can explain what the sophistication point rewards. (Guide: “Sophistication: what it is and is not”; Practice Question 6)

Skills

  • I can choose a work that offers rich, varied evidence for a given prompt. (Guide: “What the literary argument essay asks of you”; Practice Question 5)
  • I can write a thesis and three claims for a prompt. (Guide: Worked example 1; Practice Question 7)
  • I can use precise description as evidence when I cannot recall exact words, and never invent a quotation. (Guide: “Commentary on evidence from memory”; Practice Question 3)
  • I can use the commentary chain: evidence, what it shows, how it supports the claim, how that supports the thesis. (Guide: Worked example 2; Practice Question 4)

Reasoning

  • I can choose a pattern for a line of reasoning (development, layers, cause and consequence) to suit the work. (Guide: “From thesis to line of reasoning”)
  • I can develop a tension or alternative reading without losing my thesis. (Guide: “Sophistication: what it is and is not”; Practice Question 6)
  • I can revise a weak paragraph into a strong one and say what changed. (Guide: Worked example 2; Practice Question 8)
  • I can write a body paragraph with a claim, specific evidence, commentary and a link to the thesis. (Practice Question 8)

When every box is ticked, move on to the 9.7 study guide.

AP® and Advanced Placement® are trademarks registered by the College Board, which is not affiliated with, and does not endorse, this website. Marlbridge is an independent tuition provider. It is not an authorized AP course provider, an AP school or an exam centre, and these resources are not official College Board materials. Reading them or doing simulations does not meet the laboratory requirement of an AP science course.