Skip to content
Marlbridge

AP® Calculus AB · Unit 1 · Topic 1.3

Estimating Limit Values from Graphs: Practice Questions (Calculus AB 1.3)

Seven original Marlbridge practice questions on reading one-sided and two-sided limits from graphs, with jumps, holes, asymptotes, oscillation and misleading windows.

These are original Marlbridge practice questions, not past exam questions. The rubrics are a suggested Marlbridge rubric to help you check your work; they are not an official scoring guideline. Assumptions for every question: no calculator, angles in radians, and every point marked on a graph has exact coordinates. Notation: lim (x → a) f(x) means “the limit as x approaches a of f(x)”; x → a⁻ means from the left (values less than a) and x → a⁺ means from the right. This set is for both Calculus AB and Calculus BC students.

Questions 1, 2 and 5 use Figure P1.

Graph of a function g on the interval from x = −3 to x = 5 Three straight pieces. First piece: from the filled point (−3, 2) a line falls to an open circle at (0, −1). Second piece: from the filled point (0, 2) a line rises to (4, 4); on this line there is an open circle at (2, 3), and a separate filled dot sits at (2, 0) on the x-axis. Third piece: from (4, 4) a line falls to the filled point (5, 3). The second and third pieces meet at (4, 4) with no gap, making a corner. −3−2−112345x −2−112345y (−3, 2) open (0, −1) filled (0, 2) open (2, 3) filled (2, 0) (4, 4) (5, 3) y = g(x)
Figure P1. The graph of g for −3 ≤ x ≤ 5. Open circles (rings) are points the graph approaches but does not include; filled dots are values of g. Axes are unitless.

Question 1 (multiple choice · foundation)

Use Figure P1. What is lim (x → 2) g(x)?

  • (A) 0
  • (B) 2
  • (C) 3
  • (D) The limit does not exist.
Answer and explanation

Answer: (C). Follow the middle line towards x = 2 from the left: the heights approach 3. From the right, the heights also approach 3. Both sides agree, so the limit is 3.

  • (A) is g(2), the height of the filled dot. The value at x = 2 does not affect the limit.
  • (B) gives the x-value, 2, instead of the height.
  • (D) assumes a hole means no limit. A hole affects the value, not the limit: both sides still head to the same height.

Question 2 (multiple choice · core)

Use Figure P1. What is the value of lim (x → 0⁻) g(x) + lim (x → 4) g(x)?

  • (A) 3
  • (B) 5
  • (C) 6
  • (D) It does not exist, because lim (x → 0) g(x) does not exist.
Answer and explanation

Answer: (A). From the left of 0, the falling line heads to the open circle at (0, −1), so lim (x → 0⁻) g(x) = −1. At x = 4 the two lines meet at (4, 4) with no gap, so both sides approach 4 and lim (x → 4) g(x) = 4. The sum is −1 + 4 = 3.

  • (B) misreads the left-hand limit as +1: 1 + 4 = 5. The open circle is below the x-axis.
  • (C) uses the right-hand side at 0 (the filled dot at height 2) instead of the left: 2 + 4 = 6.
  • (D) confuses the one-sided limit with the two-sided one. The two-sided limit at 0 does not exist, but the question asks only for the left-hand limit, which does exist.

Question 3 (multiple choice · core)

Which of the following limits exists as a real number?

  • (A) lim (x → 3) 1/(x − 3)²
  • (B) lim (x → 0) cos(1/x)
  • (C) lim (x → −1) |x + 1|/(x + 1)
  • (D) lim (x → 1) (x − 1)²/|x − 1|
Answer and explanation

Answer: (D). For x ≠ 1, (x − 1)² = |x − 1|², so the expression equals |x − 1|. Its graph is a V shape with a hole at (1, 0). Both sides approach height 0, so the limit is 0.

  • (A) is unbounded. As x → 3 from either side, (x − 3)² is a tiny positive number, so 1/(x − 3)² grows without bound. You may write = ∞, but that describes why the limit does not exist.
  • (B) oscillates. cos(1/x) = 1 at x = 1/(2π), 1/(4π), 1/(6π), … and cos(1/x) = −1 at x = 1/π, 1/(3π), 1/(5π), … Both lists get as close to 0 as you like, so no single height is approached.
  • (C) jumps. For x > −1 the expression is 1; for x < −1 it is −1. The left-hand limit (−1) and right-hand limit (1) are different.

Question 4 (multiple choice · core)

A student graphs y = x + 0.0001/(x − 4)² on a window with −10 ≤ x ≤ 10 and −10 ≤ y ≤ 10. The screen shows what looks like the straight line y = x. Which conclusion about lim (x → 4) of this function is correct?

  • (A) The limit is 4, because the graph looks like y = x.
  • (B) The limit does not exist, because the values grow without bound as x → 4 from either side.
  • (C) The limit is 4.0001, because the extra term adds 0.0001.
  • (D) The limit does not exist, because the left-hand and right-hand limits are different.
Answer and explanation

Answer: (B). Close to 4, (x − 4)² is tiny, so the extra term is huge. At x = 3.99 or 4.01, (x − 4)² = 0.0001 and the extra term is 1, giving y ≈ 5. At x = 3.999 or 4.001, the extra term is 100, giving y ≈ 104. The values grow without bound from both sides. The spike is too narrow for the screen to show.

  • (A) trusts the picture. The window’s scale hides a very narrow vertical asymptote.
  • (C) adds 0.0001 as if the denominator were 1. The denominator (x − 4)² approaches 0, so the term does not stay small.
  • (D) gives the wrong reason. Both sides go to +∞, in the same direction. The limit fails because the function is unbounded, not because of a jump.

Question 5 (graph · core)

Use Figure P1.

(a) Find lim (x → 0⁻) g(x), lim (x → 0⁺) g(x) and g(0). (b) Does lim (x → 0) g(x) exist? Justify your answer using part (a). (c) Find lim (x → 2) g(x) and g(2). Explain why it is not a contradiction that these are different. (d) The graph starts at x = −3. Which one-sided limit at x = −3 can you find from the graph, and what is its value?

Worked solution and suggested Marlbridge rubric

(a) lim (x → 0⁻) g(x) = −1 (open circle at (0, −1)). lim (x → 0⁺) g(x) = 2. g(0) = 2 (the filled dot).

(b) No. The left-hand limit is −1 and the right-hand limit is 2. A two-sided limit exists only when both one-sided limits exist and are equal, and −1 ≠ 2.

(c) lim (x → 2) g(x) = 3, because the line approaches height 3 from both sides. g(2) = 0, from the filled dot. A limit uses only x-values near 2, never x = 2 itself, so the separate dot at (2, 0) cannot change it.

(d) Only the right-hand limit can be found, because g is not defined to the left of −3. lim (x → −3⁺) g(x) = 2.

Point What earns it
1 All three values in (a) correct: −1, 2 and 2
1 (b) “does not exist”, justified by the unequal one-sided limits (not by “there is a jump” alone without values)
1 (c) limit 3 and value 0, with the reason that a limit does not depend on the value at x = 2
1 (d) right-hand limit only, equal to 2, with the reason that there are no x-values to the left of −3

Accept any wording that quotes both one-sided limits in (b).

Question 6 (constructed response · core)

Consider three functions:

  • r(x) = 1/(x + 2)²
  • s(x) = (x + 2)/|x + 2|
  • p(x) = sin(π/x)

(a) Describe the graph of r and of s near x = −2. For each, state whether the limit as x → −2 exists. If it does not, say which kind of behaviour causes this. (b) Show that p(2/5) = 1 and p(2/7) = −1. Give two more x-values between 0 and 2/7 where p takes the values 1 and −1. Use these to explain why lim (x → 0) p(x) does not exist. (c) A student writes: “lim (x → −2) r(x) = ∞, so the limit exists and equals infinity.” Explain what is wrong.

Worked solution and suggested Marlbridge rubric

(a) r: (x + 2)² is a small positive number near x = −2, so r(x) is very large and positive on both sides. For example, r(−1.9) = 1/0.01 = 100 and r(−1.99) = 10 000. The graph rises without bound on both sides of a vertical asymptote at x = −2. The limit does not exist because r is unbounded.

s: For x > −2, x + 2 is positive, so s(x) = 1. For x < −2, x + 2 is negative, so s(x) = −1. The graph is two horizontal pieces with a gap at x = −2. The left-hand limit is −1 and the right-hand limit is 1, so the limit does not exist because the one-sided limits differ (a jump).

(b) p(2/5) = sin(5π/2) = 1 and p(2/7) = sin(7π/2) = −1. Closer to 0: p(2/9) = sin(9π/2) = 1 and p(2/11) = sin(11π/2) = −1. However close to 0 you go, p keeps taking both values 1 and −1, so the heights never settle on one number. The limit does not exist because p oscillates.

(c) ∞ is not a real number. Writing “= ∞” says the values grow without bound, which is one way a limit fails to exist. Correct statement: lim (x → −2) r(x) does not exist, because r is unbounded as x → −2.

Point What earns it
1 r: unbounded on both sides of x = −2, limit does not exist
1 s: left-hand limit −1, right-hand limit 1, limit does not exist because they differ
1 p: shows the two given values and gives two correct closer values (such as 2/9 and 2/11)
1 Explains oscillation (both 1 and −1 occur arbitrarily close to 0) and corrects the student in (c)

Accept any correct closer values in (b): x = 2/(4n + 1) gives 1 and x = 2/(4n + 3) gives −1, for whole numbers n.

Question 7 (constructed response · stretch)

A function f is defined for every real number except x = 5. It satisfies all of these:

  • lim (x → 2⁻) f(x) = 3
  • lim (x → 2⁺) f(x) = −1
  • f(2) = 1
  • lim (x → 5) f(x) = 4

(a) Describe a graph that meets all four conditions, or give a piecewise formula for one. Explain how each condition is shown. (b) Does lim (x → 2) f(x) exist? Explain. (c) A classmate says: “f(5) is undefined, so lim (x → 5) f(x) cannot be 4.” Respond. (d) Explain why a graphing calculator picture of your function might not show anything unusual at x = 5.

Worked solution and suggested Marlbridge rubric

(a) Many answers are possible. One example:

  • f(x) = x + 1 for x < 2
  • f(2) = 1
  • f(x) = (5/3)(x − 2) − 1 for x > 2, x ≠ 5

On a graph: the line y = x + 1 ends at an open circle at (2, 3), so the left-hand limit is 3. A filled dot at (2, 1) gives f(2) = 1. A second line starts with an open circle at (2, −1), so the right-hand limit is −1. It rises with gradient 5/3 and passes through height (5/3)(3) − 1 = 4 at x = 5, where there is an open circle at (5, 4) and no filled dot, so f(5) is undefined but the limit there is 4.

(b) No. The left-hand limit is 3 and the right-hand limit is −1. They are different, so the two-sided limit does not exist. The value f(2) = 1 does not change this.

(c) The classmate is wrong. A limit depends on the heights approached near x = 5, not on the value at 5. Both sides head to height 4, so the limit is 4 even with a hole there.

(d) Most graphing tools do not draw open circles, and a single missing point leaves no visible gap at normal scale. The hole exists but is invisible.

Point What earns it
1 A graph or formula with the correct one-sided limits at x = 2 (3 from the left, −1 from the right)
1 f(2) = 1 shown as a separate filled dot, and a hole at (5, 4) with no value at x = 5
1 (b) “does not exist” because 3 ≠ −1 and (c) limit depends on nearby values, not the value at 5
1 (d) explains that a single missing point (hole) is too small to show at the screen’s scale

A clear sketch with open and filled circles is as good as a formula.

How did you do?

  • Q1 or Q5(c) wrong: reread “What a graph tells you about a limit” and Worked example 1(a) in the study guide. The value at a point does not decide the limit.
  • Q2 or Q5(a)–(b) wrong: redo Worked example 1(b) and reread “One-sided and two-sided limits”.
  • Q3 or Q6 wrong: see “Three ways a limit can fail to exist” and Figure 2 in the guide.
  • Q4 or Q7(d) wrong: reread “When the picture can mislead” and Worked example 2.

Then tick off the topic checklist.

AP® and Advanced Placement® are trademarks registered by the College Board, which is not affiliated with, and does not endorse, this website. Marlbridge is an independent tuition provider. It is not an authorized AP course provider, an AP school or an exam centre, and these resources are not official College Board materials. Reading them or doing simulations does not meet the laboratory requirement of an AP science course.