Skip to content
Marlbridge

Study Guides

AQA A-Level Law: Tort (7162)

Negligence, occupiers' liability, nuisance, vicarious liability, defences and remedies – the full content of Section 3.3 for AQA A-Level Law (7162).

Subject
Law
Level
A LEVELS
Topic
Tort
Updated

Aligned to AQA A Level Law (7162), For teaching from September 2017 onwards, A-level exams 2019 onwards. Official specification .

Syllabus page (what it covers and how it is assessed): AQA A Level Law.

Syllabus topics and points this page is mapped to

7162

  • 3 Tort (topic-level mapping)

"Topic-level mapping" means this page belongs to that topic; it does not claim to cover every point in it.

Found an error? Report a correction.

Need help with this topic? Request a free trial class for A Level Law (7162).

This guide covers 3.3 Tort, the third of five subject-content sections in AQA A-level Law (7162), first teaching September 2017. It is examined on Paper 2, where it carries 75 of the paper’s 100 marks alongside 25 marks on the nature of law and the English legal system, and shares its applied-problem-question technique with the specification’s other substantive law topics. These notes complement the site’s guides to The Nature of Law and the English Legal System and General Elements of Criminal Liability.

Where this fits in 7162

Tort law governs civil liability between individuals – primarily claims for negligence – distinct from Criminal Law’s focus on offences against the state. The reasoning technique carries across from Criminal Law (identify the relevant rule, apply it to the facts, reach a conclusion) but the substantive content here is entirely new: duty of care, breach, causation, and a set of specific torts beyond negligence.

Syllabus coverage

AQA A-LEVEL LAW (7162) – 3.3 TORT

  • The rules of tort law: liability and fault in negligence, occupiers’ liability, nuisance and vicarious liability, plus associated defences and remedies
  • Theory of tort law: the public policy factors governing the imposition of a duty of care (the Caparo three-part test) for physical injury and property damage; policy factors governing liability for pure economic loss and psychiatric injury; the factors governing the objective standard of care; the factors governing the grant of an injunction; the nature and purpose of vicarious liability
  • Liability in negligence for physical injury and property damage: duty of care (the ‘neighbour’ principle; the Caparo three-part test); breach of duty (the objective standard of care); damage (factual causation and legal causation/remoteness of damage)
  • Liability in negligence for economic loss and psychiatric injury: pure economic loss caused by negligent acts and negligent misstatements; psychiatric injury sustained by primary and secondary victims
  • Occupiers’ liability: liability to visitors (Occupiers’ Liability Act 1957) and to trespassers (Occupiers’ Liability Act 1984)
  • Nuisance and the escape of dangerous things: private nuisance; the rule in Rylands v Fletcher
  • Vicarious liability: nature and purpose; testing employment status; other areas of application
  • Defences: contributory negligence; consent (volenti non fit injuria); defences specific to private nuisance and Rylands v Fletcher
  • Remedies: compensatory damages for physical injury, property damage and economic loss; mitigation of loss; injunctions

How to approach it

Negligence is the backbone of this topic and the model for almost everything else in it: duty, breach, causation, in that fixed order, every time. Learn that three-stage structure so thoroughly that it becomes automatic, then treat occupiers’ liability, nuisance and vicarious liability as variations that either replace or add to one of those three stages (occupiers’ liability replaces the general duty of care with a statutory one; vicarious liability adds a question about who else can be held liable, on top of an underlying tort).

Negligence runs duty, breach, damage. Occupiers' liability replaces the general duty of care with a statutory duty. Vicarious liability adds a second party who can be held liable on top of an underlying tort; it is a route, not a stand-alone tort.
Occupiers' liability swaps the duty stage; vicarious liability adds a second liable party.

Official syllabus

AQA A-level Law (7162) specification, first teaching September 2017 – aqa.org.uk.

Negligence: the three-stage test

Duty of care asks whether the law recognises an obligation between the parties at all – established either by precedent or, in novel situations, the Caparo three-part test. Breach asks whether the defendant fell below the objective standard of a reasonable person in their position. Damage asks whether the breach factually caused the harm, and whether that harm was a legally recognised, not too remote, consequence. A claim fails if any one of the three stages is not satisfied, regardless of how strong the other two are.

A flow of three stages: duty of care, breach, and damage, with damage split into factual cause and legal cause. A claim fails if any one stage is not met. If all three are made out the claim is established.
Negligence runs duty, breach, damage in a fixed order, and failing any one stage defeats the claim.
A decision picture: if the duty situation is already established by precedent, the duty exists and Caparo need not be applied. If the situation is novel, the Caparo three-part test is applied. Either way the next question is breach.
Check precedent first; use the Caparo test only for a novel duty situation.

Beyond straightforward negligence: two special categories

Pure economic loss (financial loss unconnected to physical injury or damage) and psychiatric injury (harm not accompanied by physical injury) are both treated more restrictively than ordinary physical injury or property damage claims, for policy reasons – courts are wary of unlimited liability for purely financial consequences, and psychiatric injury claims are further split between primary victims (those in the actual danger zone) and secondary victims (witnesses), who face additional control mechanisms before a claim succeeds.

Three rows with a claim arrow meeting a gate. Physical injury and property damage meet a wide gate. Pure economic loss and psychiatric injury meet narrow gates because courts are wary of unlimited liability. Gate widths are illustrative.
Pure economic loss and psychiatric injury are treated more restrictively than physical injury or property damage.
A schematic, not to scale. An incident sits at the centre of a danger zone. A primary victim is inside the actual danger zone. A secondary victim is a witness outside it and faces extra control mechanisms before a claim succeeds.
Primary victims are in the danger zone; secondary victims witness events and face additional control mechanisms.

Occupiers’ liability: two Acts, two categories of claimant

The Occupiers’ Liability Act 1957 governs liability to lawful visitors; the Occupiers’ Liability Act 1984 governs the more limited liability owed to trespassers. Confusing which Act applies to which claimant is one of the most common structural errors in this section – the standard of care and the scope of duty differ meaningfully between the two.

A fenced plot of land with a house. A lawful visitor enters through the gate and the Occupiers' Liability Act 1957 applies. A trespasser crosses the fence and the Occupiers' Liability Act 1984 applies, with more limited liability. The standard of care and scope of duty differ.
The 1957 Act governs lawful visitors and the 1984 Act governs trespassers.

Worked example: applying the negligence structure

The routine below is an original model written for this resource, not a reproduction of any official past paper or mark scheme.

Step 1 - identify the specific duty question:
Is this an established duty situation, or does Caparo need
applying?

Step 2 - assess breach against the objective standard:
What would a reasonable person in the defendant's position have
done?

Step 3 - test factual causation:
"But for" the breach, would the harm have occurred?

Step 4 - test legal causation (remoteness):
Was this type of harm a reasonably foreseeable consequence?

Step 5 - only then consider defences and remedies:
Contributory negligence or consent may reduce or defeat the claim
even where all three negligence elements are made out.

Step 5 is often missed under time pressure: candidates who establish negligence successfully sometimes forget that a defence can still reduce or entirely defeat an otherwise complete claim.

A staircase of five steps: duty (established or Caparo), breach (reasonable person standard), factual cause (but for), legal cause (reasonably foreseeable harm), then defences and remedies, which can still reduce or defeat a complete claim and are often missed.
Work through duty, breach, factual then legal cause, and only then defences and remedies.

Common mistakes

Applying the Caparo test to situations where duty is already established by precedent (unnecessary and time-costing). Confusing the subjective and objective standards of care. Skipping legal causation (remoteness) after establishing factual causation. Applying the wrong Occupiers’ Liability Act to a trespasser or visitor. Treating vicarious liability as a standalone tort rather than a route to holding a second party liable for an underlying tort committed by someone else.

Quick revision checklist

  • State and apply the three-stage negligence test: duty, breach, damage.
  • Explain when and how the Caparo three-part test applies to a novel duty situation.
  • Distinguish liability for pure economic loss and psychiatric injury from ordinary physical injury claims.
  • Correctly match the 1957 or 1984 Occupiers’ Liability Act to the claimant’s status.
  • Identify available defences and remedies, and apply them after (not instead of) the main tort analysis.

Frequently asked questions

Which AQA A Level Law paper examines tort? Tort is examined on Paper 2 of AQA A Level Law 7162, where it carries 75 of the paper’s 100 marks alongside 25 marks on the nature of law and the English legal system.

What are the three stages of negligence? Negligence has three stages: duty of care, breach of duty against the objective standard of a reasonable person, and damage caused by the breach, both factually and legally. A claim fails if any one stage is not met.

When do you need the Caparo test? Use the Caparo three-part test for novel duty situations. Applying it where a duty is already established by precedent is unnecessary and wastes time.

Is vicarious liability a separate tort? No. Vicarious liability is a route to holding a second party, such as an employer, liable for an underlying tort committed by someone else.

Get free revision emails (optional)

Occasional emails with practice questions, worked explanations and links to free resources for the qualification and subjects you choose. No spam, and you can unsubscribe from any email. The free tools on this site never need an email.

Subjects (optional, up to 6)

Choose a qualification to see its subjects.

Related resources

Related articles

Studying this with a teacher

Working through Law A LEVELS?

This page is free and stays free. If you would rather be taught it, Marlbridge runs Law classes one-to-one and in small groups of up to 15, online in your own time zone. The first trial class is free. WhatsApp replies within an hour (8am–11pm Pakistan time, every day); email the same day.

AQA Law teachers at Marlbridge