Skip to content
Marlbridge

Study Guides

Cambridge A-Level Sociology (9699): Traditional Media and the New Media

Cambridge 9699 section 9.1 in depth: integration and convergence, conglomerates and platforms, who controls the media, and whether new media undermine old.

Subject
Sociology
Level
A LEVEL
Topic
Paper 4 – Globalisation, Media and Religion
Updated

Aligned to Cambridge A Level Sociology (9699), 2024-2026. Official specification .

Syllabus page (what it covers and how it is assessed): Cambridge A Level Sociology.

Syllabus points this page covers

9699 (A Level)

  • 9.1 Traditional media and the new media

Found an error? Report a correction.

Need help with this topic? Request a free trial class for A Level Sociology (9699).

Section 9.1 of Cambridge International A Level Sociology (9699), Traditional media and the new media, opens the Media section of Paper 4 under heading 9, Ownership and control of media. The syllabus lists four points: trends affecting the organisation of the media, including cross-media ownership, digitalisation, media conglomerates and social media; debates about who controls the media; differences between the traditional media and the new media; and the debate about whether the traditional media has been undermined by the growth of the new media. Heading 9 links these to Power, control and resistance and Social change and development.

The media ownership, control and the new media guide summarises all of heading 9. This page works through 9.1 in more detail. Use it with the traditional and new media revision notes and the traditional and new media practice questions.

Concentration and integration

Media companies grow in recognisable ways, and naming the type of growth makes an answer precise.

Type of growth Meaning Why it matters
Horizontal integration Buying companies at the same stage in the same industry, such as one newspaper group buying another Fewer independent voices in that medium
Vertical integration Owning several stages of production and distribution, such as a film studio that also owns cinemas or a streaming service Control from making content to delivering it
Cross-media ownership Owning different kinds of media: press, television, film, online Influence spreads across formats; content can be promoted across them
Diversification Expanding into non-media businesses Media become one part of wider corporate interests

Media conglomerates are the result: very large corporations with interests across many media and often beyond them. The Walt Disney Company’s purchase of most of 21st Century Fox, completed in 2019, is a recent example of a merger that combined film studios, television channels and streaming. Conglomerates seek synergy, where one part of the business promotes another, as when a film, its soundtrack, a theme-park ride and merchandise are marketed together.

Digitalisation and convergence

Digitalisation turns text, sound and images into the same digital code. This makes convergence possible in three senses:

  • Technological: one device (a smartphone) carries news, film, music, games and messaging.
  • Economic: companies once in separate industries (telephone, broadcasting, computing) now compete in the same markets.
  • Cultural: audiences move between platforms and also create and share content.

Social media and platform companies

Social media are platforms on which users create, share and comment on content. A small number of platform companies now operate on a global scale, for example Alphabet (owner of Google and YouTube) and Meta, which bought Instagram in 2012 and WhatsApp in 2014. These firms mainly distribute and rank content rather than produce it, but their algorithms decide what billions of people see, so they have become a new kind of gatekeeper.

Differences between traditional and new media

Martin Lister and colleagues’ New Media: A Critical Introduction (2003) identify features that distinguish new media, including digitality, interactivity, hypertextuality (linked content that users navigate in their own order) and virtuality (immersive, simulated environments such as online games). Production and consumption are also spread across many people and places rather than concentrated in a few organisations.

Dimension Traditional media New media
Direction of communication One-to-many Many-to-many; users reply and share
Who produces Professional organisations Professionals plus users (user-generated content)
Gatekeeping Editors and producers Algorithms, moderators and users’ own sharing
Time Scheduled On demand and continuous
Reach Mostly national Global by default
Regulation National regulators and laws Harder to regulate across borders
Revenue Sales, licence fees, advertising Targeted advertising based on user data; subscriptions

Use the table critically: the line is blurred. Newspapers publish online, broadcasters run streaming services, and social media carry professional content. Andrew Chadwick’s The Hybrid Media System (2013) argues that older and newer media logics now operate together, so the useful question is how they combine rather than which one has won.

Debates about who controls the media

  • Owners (instrumental Marxist view): proprietors use ownership to shape content. The closure of the News of the World in 2011, after revelations of phone hacking, led to public scrutiny of the power of Rupert Murdoch’s News International and its relationships with politicians.
  • Managers and journalists: in large corporations day-to-day decisions are taken by editors and managers; professional norms of journalism limit owners’ interference.
  • Audiences (pluralist view): in a competitive market, audiences “vote” with their attention.
  • The state: governments license broadcasters, set laws and, in some countries, censor heavily; China’s internet controls, often called the “Great Firewall”, block many foreign platforms. Regulators such as Ofcom in the United Kingdom (established 2003) set standards for broadcasters.
  • Platforms and algorithms: a newer answer is that control lies with the companies whose software ranks content, and with advertisers whose spending funds it.
  • Users: Axel Bruns described gatewatching (2005): users select and share material from many sources, so audiences take on some of the gatekeeping role.

A strong essay shows that these are not exclusive: owners, states and platforms may all exercise control, and the balance differs by country and medium.

Has the traditional media been undermined?

Arguments that it has

  • Print circulation and scheduled television audiences have fallen in many countries, and advertising has moved to search and social platforms.
  • News is increasingly encountered through social media feeds, so traditional organisations lose direct contact with audiences.
  • Citizen journalism and smartphone footage can break stories before professional newsrooms.
  • Trust in traditional news organisations has fallen in some societies.

Arguments that it has not

  • James Curran, Natalie Fenton and Des Freedman’s Misunderstanding the Internet (2012) argued that early predictions of an internet revolution were exaggerated: established companies adapted, and the most-used news sites are often run by traditional organisations.
  • Traditional media still set much of the agenda that social media discuss; many shared stories start in newspapers or broadcast news.
  • Concentration has moved rather than disappeared: the largest new-media companies are themselves conglomerates.
  • Traditional organisations have adopted new media techniques (paywalls, podcasts, streaming).

Reaching a judgement

The hybrid media system idea gives a useful conclusion: traditional media have been weakened economically and have lost their monopoly over gatekeeping, but they have not been replaced. Their content, brands and agenda-setting power remain central inside a system that now includes platforms and users.

Annotated model paragraph

Question focus: evaluate the view that the new media has undermined the traditional media.

Supporters of the view point to the movement of advertising from print and television to search and social platforms, which has weakened the finances of many newspapers. [AO1: knowledge of trend] However, Curran, Fenton and Freedman (2012) argue that established organisations adapted by moving online, and their websites remain among the most visited news sources. [AO3: counter-evidence] Chadwick’s idea of a hybrid media system (2013) suggests that the old and the new now depend on each other, as when a broadcaster’s investigation is spread through social media. [AO2: application] The traditional media has therefore been weakened as a business more than it has been undermined as a source of news. [AO3: judgement]

Common mistakes

  • Defining cross-media ownership as “owning lots of media”; specify different types of media.
  • Treating “new media” as only social media; the term also covers streaming, online news and digital games.
  • Describing differences in a list without evaluating whether the distinction still holds.
  • Assuming that because anyone can publish, everyone is heard; attention is still concentrated.
  • Using circulation or audience figures you cannot source.

Exam technique

  • Explain questions on trends: name the trend, explain the process and give its consequence for control or content.
  • Evaluate questions on undermining: give both sides, then a judgement such as the hybrid system argument.
  • Connect 9.1 to 9.2: ownership trends are evidence for Marxist theories, while audience choice and gatewatching support pluralism.
  • Connect to 9.3: if traditional media are weakened, ask whether that challenges existing power structures or simply shifts power to platform companies.

Get free revision emails (optional)

Occasional emails with practice questions, worked explanations and links to free resources for the qualification and subjects you choose. No spam, and you can unsubscribe from any email. The free tools on this site never need an email.

Subjects (optional, up to 6)

Choose a qualification to see its subjects.

Related resources

Related articles

Studying this with a teacher

Working through Sociology A LEVEL?

This page is free and stays free. If you would rather be taught it, Marlbridge runs Sociology classes one-to-one and in small groups of up to 15, online in your own time zone. The first trial class is free. WhatsApp replies within an hour (8am–11pm Pakistan time, every day); email the same day.

Cambridge Sociology teachers at Marlbridge