Skip to content
Marlbridge

Study Guides

Cambridge A Level Sociology (9699): Religion and post-modernity

A deeper guide to 9699 section 12.3: privatised religion, spiritual shopping, resacralisation, NRMs and New Age ideas, and five explanations of fundamentalism.

Subject
Sociology
Level
A LEVEL
Topic
Paper 4 – Globalisation, Media and Religion
Updated

Aligned to Cambridge A Level Sociology (9699), 2024-2026. Official specification .

Syllabus page (what it covers and how it is assessed): Cambridge A Level Sociology.

Syllabus points this page covers

9699 (A Level)

  • 12.3 Religion and post-modernity

Found an error? Report a correction.

Need help with this topic? Request a free trial class for A Level Sociology (9699).

Section 12.3 of Cambridge International A Level Sociology (9699) asks whether religion in post-modern societies is disappearing or simply changing shape. The syllabus has five content points: whether there has been a growth in privatised religion; the concept of spiritual shopping and its contribution to understanding religiosity today; debates about whether resacralisation is a feature of post-modernity; the significance of new religious movements (NRMs) and New Age ideas; and explanations for the growth of fundamentalist religions, including cultural defence, cultural transition, disengagement, marginality and religious revival.

The secularisation, feminism and post-modern religion guide introduces Lyon, Hervieu-Léger, the Kendal Project and Wallis’s typology. This guide explains what “post-modernity” adds to the analysis, develops each syllabus point with further studies, and shows how to use the five explanations of fundamentalism evaluatively.

Syllabus coverage

Cambridge International AS & A Level Sociology 9699 (2024–2026), Paper 4 Section C (Religion), heading 12 The influence of religion, sub-topic 12.3:

  • Whether there has been a growth in privatised religion.
  • Spiritual shopping and its contribution to understanding religiosity today.
  • Whether resacralisation is a feature of post-modernity.
  • The significance of NRMs and New Age ideas for understanding religion today.
  • Explanations for the growth of fundamentalist religions: cultural defence, cultural transition, disengagement, marginality and religious revival.

Paper 4 essays are worth 35 marks each and must explore contrasting views or evidence. The section links to the key concept of Inequality and opportunity through the analysis of fundamentalism.

What does “post-modernity” add?

Post-modern theorists describe a society marked by fragmentation, choice, consumption and media-saturated culture. Jean-François Lyotard (1979) described post-modernity as “incredulity towards metanarratives”: grand stories claiming to explain everything, including religious ones, lose authority. Applied to religion, this produces three predictions:

  1. Belief becomes individual and chosen rather than inherited.
  2. Religious ideas are mixed, borrowed and consumed like other cultural products.
  3. Religion does not vanish; it reappears in new forms and places.

These predictions give an alternative to secularisation (section 12.1): the same fall in attendance may mean relocation, not decline.

Growth in privatised religion?

Thomas Luckmann’s The Invisible Religion (1967) argued that religion was not disappearing but moving from public institutions into the private sphere, where individuals construct their own systems of meaning. Supporting evidence includes personal prayer, meditation and spiritual practice outside organisations, and the use of media and the internet. Christopher Helland distinguished religion online (organisations sending information to followers, top-down) from online religion (people creating religious practice and community interactively). Online religion fits the idea of privatised, self-directed belief.

Evaluation: private belief is hard to measure, so claims of growth rest on limited evidence; Bruce argues privatised faith is weaker because it lacks the social support that keeps belief plausible; and in many societies religion remains public and political (sections 11.3 and 12.1).

Spiritual shopping

Spiritual shopping describes individuals selecting beliefs and practices that suit them from a wide market. Its contribution to understanding religiosity is to explain why measures based on membership may miss real spiritual activity.

  • Danièle Hervieu-Léger links this to cultural amnesia: religion was once handed down as a “chain of memory” through families and communities. As that chain breaks, people no longer inherit a fixed religion and instead assemble their own.
  • Wade Clark Roof, studying the American baby-boom generation, described a “spiritual marketplace” of seekers moving between traditions.
  • David Lyon connects choice to consumer culture and media, which “disembed” religion from particular places and communities.

Evaluation: spiritual shopping may describe affluent, educated Western groups more than religious life globally; Bruce sees pick-and-mix belief as evidence of secularisation, because loosely held beliefs have little effect on behaviour and are rarely passed on to children.

Is resacralisation a feature of post-modernity?

Resacralisation means the return of the sacred: renewed interest in religion and spirituality. The syllabus spells the term “resacrilisation”; either spelling is understood. Evidence includes:

  • Pentecostal and charismatic growth. David Martin’s Tongues of Fire (1990) traced rapid Pentecostal expansion in Latin America.
  • Holistic spirituality. The Kendal Project found it growing, though from a small base.
  • NRMs, New Age and fundamentalism (below).
  • Religion in public life, from faith-based political movements to religious responses to national crises.

Debate: is this resacralisation a feature of post-modernity (a response to uncertainty, choice and the collapse of metanarratives), or simply evidence that secularisation was never universal? Growth in the global South may be driven by migration to cities and insecurity, which are features of modernisation rather than post-modernity.

NRMs and New Age ideas

What NRMs show about religion today

  • Eileen Barker, The Making of a Moonie (1984), studied the Unification Church. She found that most people who attended its recruitment workshops did not join, challenging claims that members were “brainwashed”. This suggests membership is a choice, even in demanding groups.
  • Explanations for joining: marginality and relative deprivation (Wallis’s world-rejecting movements appeal to those on the edges of society); social change and anomie; and a search for meaning or self-improvement (world-affirming movements appeal to successful people seeking more).
  • Dynamics: H. Richard Niebuhr (1929) argued that sects tend to be short-lived or to become denominations once the founding generation passes.

New Age ideas. Paul Heelas, in The New Age Movement (1996), identified self-spirituality (the sacred is found within the self) and detraditionalisation (personal experience replaces external authority) as the core of New Age thought. These features make New Age ideas a clear example of post-modern religion: chosen, individual and suspicious of institutions.

Significance: NRMs and New Age groups are small in membership, so their significance lies less in numbers than in what they reveal: a persistent demand for meaning, and a shift from obedience to self-development.

Explanations for the growth of fundamentalism

Fundamentalist movements typically claim a return to the literal truth of sacred texts, draw sharp boundaries between believers and outsiders, and react against modern relativism, while often using modern media skilfully.

Explanation Core idea Fits best when
Cultural defence Religion becomes a focus of group identity against an external threat (Bruce) A nation or minority feels dominated by an outside power
Cultural transition Religion helps people cope with the upheaval of migration or rapid change and keeps identity Migrants in a new society; rural migrants to cities
Disengagement Believers withdraw from a society they see as corrupt, creating separate communities Groups rejecting secular or permissive culture
Marginality Deprived or excluded groups turn to movements offering certainty and hope Poverty, unemployment, political exclusion
Religious revival Renewal movements respond to perceived moral decline and reassert tradition Periods of rapid moral or social change

Other theorists to add:

  • Anthony Giddens: fundamentalism is “tradition defended in the traditional way”, a reaction to globalisation and uncertainty.
  • Zygmunt Bauman: post-modern freedom brings anxiety; fundamentalism appeals to those who want certainty instead of endless choice.
  • Manuel Castells, The Power of Identity (1997): fundamentalism as resistance identity, formed by groups who feel excluded by global change, contrasted with project identity, which builds new identities to transform society.
  • Bruce distinguishes fundamentalism in the West, often a reaction to internal diversity and secular culture, from movements elsewhere reacting to change imposed from outside.

Evaluating the explanations: they overlap (marginalised migrants may experience cultural transition and marginality together); they are better at explaining why people join than why movements grow at particular times; and the label “fundamentalism” can be applied loosely to very different groups, so essays should define it and use specific cases.

Worked example: applying the five explanations

Original practice question: “Marginality is the main reason for the growth of fundamentalist religions.” Evaluate this view. [35]

Plan: define fundamentalism; explain marginality with Weber’s theodicy of disprivilege and support from deprived urban populations; test it against cultural defence (membership spanning all classes in a threatened nation), cultural transition (migrants who are not necessarily poor), disengagement (educated believers withdrawing by choice) and revival; add Castells and Bauman for global and post-modern context; conclude that marginality explains part of the appeal, but the growth of movements that recruit across classes shows that identity and uncertainty matter as much as deprivation.

Common mistakes

  • Describing NRMs with Wallis’s typology but never saying why they matter today.
  • Treating spiritual shopping as automatically disproving secularisation.
  • Listing the five fundamentalism explanations with no evaluation of where each fits.
  • Using “post-modern” to mean simply “modern” or “recent”.
  • Labelling groups as fundamentalist without defining the term.

Command words in Paper 4

Evaluate essays in 12.3 reward judgement about significance: how widespread a change is, whom it affects and whether it shows change or decline.

Keep going

Get free revision emails (optional)

Occasional emails with practice questions, worked explanations and links to free resources for the qualification and subjects you choose. No spam, and you can unsubscribe from any email. The free tools on this site never need an email.

Subjects (optional, up to 6)

Choose a qualification to see its subjects.

Related resources

Related articles

Studying this with a teacher

Working through Sociology A LEVEL?

This page is free and stays free. If you would rather be taught it, Marlbridge runs Sociology classes one-to-one and in small groups of up to 15, online in your own time zone. The first trial class is free. WhatsApp replies within an hour (8am–11pm Pakistan time, every day); email the same day.

Cambridge Sociology teachers at Marlbridge