Study Guides
Cambridge A-Level Sociology (9699): Religion and Social Order
Cambridge 9699 section 11.2 in depth: Durkheim and later functionalists, Marx and neo-Marxists on religion and oppression, and how to weigh the two views.
- Subject
- Sociology
- Level
- A LEVEL
- Topic
- Paper 4 – Globalisation, Media and Religion
- Author
- Marlbridge Academic Team
- Updated
- Reviewed by
- Naqiya Yousaf (what this means)
Aligned to Cambridge A Level Sociology (9699), 2024-2026. Official specification .
Syllabus page (what it covers and how it is assessed): Cambridge A Level Sociology.
Syllabus points this page covers
9699 (A Level)
- 11.2 Religion and social order
Found an error? Report a correction.
Need help with this topic? Request a free trial class for A Level Sociology (9699).
Section 11.2 of Cambridge International A Level Sociology (9699), Religion and social order, is the theoretical core of heading 11 in Paper 4. The syllabus lists three points: functionalist accounts of how religion contributes to social order and social solidarity; Marxist accounts of the relationship between religion, oppression and capitalism; and debates about the strengths and limitations of functionalist and Marxist perspectives on religion. Heading 11 links this to Power, control and resistance and asks for a contrast between structural and interactionist theories.
The religion, social order and social change guide introduces Durkheim, Malinowski, Parsons, Bellah, Marx and Maduro. This page goes further into how each argument works, the evidence for it and the criticisms that matter in a 35-mark essay. Use it with the religion and social order revision notes and the religion and social order practice questions.
Functionalist accounts
Durkheim’s argument step by step
Émile Durkheim’s The Elementary Forms of Religious Life (1912) is the starting point.
- Sacred and profane. Every religion divides the world into the sacred, things set apart and treated with awe, and the profane, ordinary things of everyday life.
- Totemism. Durkheim used ethnographic reports on Aboriginal Australian clans, whose totems (often an animal or plant) were sacred symbols of the clan.
- The totem symbolises society. When clan members worship the totem, they are in effect worshipping their own society, the power that existed before them and will outlast them.
- Collective effervescence. At collective ceremonies, the shared intense emotion makes people feel part of something greater than themselves.
- Collective conscience. Ritual reinforces the shared norms, values and beliefs that make social life possible, producing social solidarity.
- Cognitive functions. Durkheim also argued that religion gave humans the basic categories of thought, such as time, space and cause, so it is the origin of shared ways of thinking.
Durkheim on the future. He expected traditional religion to weaken as societies became more complex and individualistic, but predicted that new forms of shared belief, such as a “cult of the individual” stressing human rights, would take its place.
Later functionalists
- Malinowski: religion helps individuals cope with situations of emotional stress and uncertainty that threaten social order, such as death or danger. Funeral rites, for example, reintegrate the bereaved and reaffirm the group’s continuity.
- Talcott Parsons: religion provides core values that become the basis of norms (for example, Christian ideas reflected in law) and answers “ultimate questions” about suffering and injustice, helping people adjust to events that might otherwise undermine commitment to society.
- Robert Bellah: civil religion integrates a religiously diverse society around shared sacred symbols of the nation.
Evidence that supports functionalism
- National ceremonies, remembrance days and royal or state funerals show ritual creating collective emotion.
- Religion’s role in rites of passage (birth, marriage, death) continues even where attendance has fallen.
- Religious communities often provide support and solidarity in times of crisis.
Criticisms of functionalism
- Peter Worsley (1956) argued that Durkheim’s evidence was flawed: there is no sharp division between sacred and profane among Aboriginal Australians, and different clans can share the same totems, so totems cannot simply symbolise one clan.
- Religious conflict. Religion can divide societies rather than unite them. Samuel Huntington’s The Clash of Civilizations and the Remaking of World Order (1996) argued that after the Cold War conflict would increasingly occur between civilisations defined largely by religion. Critics dispute his thesis, but religious conflict between and within societies challenges the idea that religion is a source of solidarity.
- Diversity. Durkheim’s theory fits small societies with one religion; it is harder to apply to modern societies with many faiths and many non-believers.
- Change. Functionalism neglects religion as a source of change (11.3).
Marxist accounts
Marx’s argument
Karl Marx wrote that “religion is the sigh of the oppressed creature, the heart of a heartless world, and the soul of soulless conditions. It is the opium of the people” (1844). The fuller passage matters: religion is a response to real suffering, but one that dulls awareness of its causes.
| Function in Marx’s account | How it works | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Ideology | Presents inequality as natural or God-given | Divine right of kings; hierarchy presented as sacred order |
| Compensation | Promises reward in an afterlife for suffering now | “The meek shall inherit the earth” as consolation |
| Legitimation of the ruling class | Religious institutions ally with the powerful | Established churches owning land and supporting rulers |
| Product of alienation | Workers who lack control over their lives project their hopes onto a god | Religion flourishes where people feel powerless |
Lenin (1905) called religion “a kind of spiritual gin” in which the slaves of capital drown their human image. Marx expected religion to disappear once a classless society removed the suffering that produced it.
Historical evidence
- The Halévy thesis: the historian Élie Halévy argued that Methodism helped prevent a revolution in England by channelling working-class discontent into religious enthusiasm. E.P. Thompson’s The Making of the English Working Class (1963) also discussed Methodism’s role in disciplining workers.
- Caste: religious ideas about purity and rebirth can present a rigid social hierarchy as part of a sacred order.
Neo-Marxist developments
- Engels noted that early Christianity began as a movement of oppressed people, so religion can have a radical side.
- Antonio Gramsci saw religion as part of the struggle for hegemony: it can support ruling-class ideas, but clergy can also act as “organic intellectuals” who help the working class develop alternative ideas.
- Dwight Billings (1990) compared coal miners and textile workers in Kentucky. Among miners, some lay preachers supported union struggles and used religious language to justify them, while textile workers in company-dominated communities were more conservative. Religion therefore supported both resistance and accommodation, depending on who controlled it.
- Otto Maduro (1982) argued that religion has relative autonomy from the economy.
Criticisms of Marxism
- Ignores religion’s positive functions for individuals and communities.
- Treats believers as victims of false consciousness, denying their own understanding.
- Cannot easily explain religion as a force for change, such as liberation theology (11.3).
- Religion persists in societies that tried to abolish class or repress religion.
Weighing the two perspectives
| Functionalism | Marxism | |
|---|---|---|
| What religion does | Integrates society, creates solidarity | Legitimates inequality, dulls resistance |
| Who benefits | Society as a whole | The ruling class |
| Shared assumption | Religion is conservative: it maintains the existing order | Religion is conservative: it maintains the existing order |
| Main weakness | Ignores conflict and inequality | Ignores consensus and individual meaning |
Key evaluative points
- Both are structural theories that underplay how believers interpret religion. Peter Berger’s The Sacred Canopy (1967) offers a phenomenological alternative: religion provides a “canopy” of meaning that makes the world feel ordered and secure. This still supports order, but explains it through individuals’ need for meaning rather than society’s needs.
- Both see religion as conservative, so both are challenged by evidence that religion drives change.
- Feminists argue both ignore patriarchy: religion may maintain gender inequality (12.2).
- Secularisation and religious diversity (heading 12) weaken both theories’ assumption of a single dominant religion.
Annotated model paragraph
Question focus: evaluate the view that religion maintains social order.
Durkheim argued that collective rituals create collective effervescence, reinforcing the shared values that hold society together. [AO1] National ceremonies in many modern societies, where religious and civic symbols combine, suggest this still happens. [AO2: application] However, Worsley showed that Durkheim’s own evidence was weak, and Marxists argue that the “order” religion maintains is one of inequality. [AO3: criticism and alternative] Billings’s study of Kentucky miners shows that the same religion can also fuel resistance. [AO3: evidence] Religion often supports order, but whose order and for how long depends on who controls religious institutions. [AO3: judgement]
Common mistakes
- Quoting “opium of the people” without explaining what Marx meant by it.
- Presenting Durkheim without the steps of his argument (sacred, totem, effervescence, solidarity).
- Forgetting that both theories see religion as conservative.
- Writing two separate descriptions instead of comparing them, which the third syllabus point asks for.
- Ignoring neo-Marxist complexity.
Exam technique
- For explain questions, give the mechanism (ritual creates collective conscience; compensation dulls resistance) and an example.
- For evaluate questions, set functionalism and Marxism against each other, then bring in neo-Marxist, interactionist and feminist criticisms.
- Link forward to 11.3: Weber and liberation theology are the main evidence that religion can cause change rather than maintain order.
Get free revision emails (optional)
Occasional emails with practice questions, worked explanations and links to free resources for the qualification and subjects you choose. No spam, and you can unsubscribe from any email. The free tools on this site never need an email.
Related resources
-
Practice questions
Cambridge A-Level Sociology (9699): Religion and Social Order – Practice Questions
Twelve original Cambridge 9699 questions on section 11.2: Durkheim, functionalism, Marx and neo-Marxists on religion and order, and limitations, with answers.
Sociology · Cambridge · A Level
Try questions -
Revision notes
Cambridge A-Level Sociology (9699): Religion and Social Order – Revision Notes
Condensed 9699 notes on section 11.2: Durkheim's argument, later functionalists, Marx, Lenin and neo-Marxists, criticisms of each, and a 12-question self-test.
Sociology · Cambridge · A Level
Revise topic -
Study guides
Cambridge A-Level Sociology (9699): Religion and Society
Cambridge 9699 section 11.1 in depth: defining religion, measuring belief, religiosity by class, gender, ethnicity and age, and other belief systems.
Sociology · Cambridge · A Level
Read guide
Related articles
-
teaching
Sociology tuition online: GCSE, IGCSE, O Level and A Level
Which Sociology specifications Marlbridge teaches live online, how the papers are set out, where students usually lose marks, and how a trial class works.
9 October 2026
-
teaching
A Level tuition in Dubai: Cambridge or Pearson Edexcel International A Level?
Schools in Dubai and Abu Dhabi teach either Cambridge International AS & A Level or Pearson Edexcel International A Level. How the two are structured, why it matters for tuition, and how online classes from Lahore work.
9 October 2026
Studying this with a teacher
Working through Sociology A LEVEL?
This page is free and stays free. If you would rather be taught it, Marlbridge runs Sociology classes one-to-one and in small groups of up to 15, online in your own time zone. The first trial class is free. WhatsApp replies within an hour (8am–11pm Pakistan time, every day); email the same day.
Cambridge Sociology teachers at Marlbridge