Skip to content
Marlbridge

Study Guides

Cambridge A-Level Sociology (9699): Religion and Society

Cambridge 9699 section 11.1 in depth: defining religion, measuring belief, religiosity by class, gender, ethnicity and age, and other belief systems.

Subject
Sociology
Level
A LEVEL
Topic
Paper 4 – Globalisation, Media and Religion
Updated

Aligned to Cambridge A Level Sociology (9699), 2024-2026. Official specification .

Syllabus page (what it covers and how it is assessed): Cambridge A Level Sociology.

Syllabus points this page covers

9699 (A Level)

  • 11.1 Religion and society

Found an error? Report a correction.

Need help with this topic? Request a free trial class for A Level Sociology (9699).

Section 11.1 of Cambridge International A Level Sociology (9699), Religion and society, opens the Religion section of Paper 4 under heading 11, Religion and social order. The syllabus lists four points: ways of defining religion; difficulties in measuring religious belief; social groups and religiosity, including class, gender, ethnicity and age; and religion and other belief systems. Heading 11 asks candidates to contrast structural and interactionist theories, and 11.1 is where that contrast starts, because how you define and measure religion decides what you find.

The religion, social order and social change guide gives a summary of 11.1. This page explains the debates behind it in more depth. Use it with the religion and society revision notes and the religion and society practice questions.

Ways of defining religion

Definitions fall into three families: substantive (what religion is), functional (what it does) and social constructionist (what people say it is). Beyond the overview, three points deepen an answer.

Inclusive and exclusive definitions

  • Exclusive definitions, usually substantive, draw a tight boundary around religion, typically belief in the supernatural. They make comparison easier and make it possible to measure decline.
  • Inclusive definitions, usually functional, include anything that performs religious functions. Nationalism, sport or political ideologies may then count, which makes religion seem universal and secularisation hard to prove.

Durkheim’s and Geertz’s definitions

  • Émile Durkheim (1912) defined religion as a unified system of beliefs and practices relative to sacred things, which unite those who adhere to them into a single moral community. The definition combines substance (the sacred) with function (moral community).
  • Clifford Geertz (“Religion as a Cultural System”, 1966) defined religion as a system of symbols that establishes powerful, pervasive and long-lasting moods and motivations by formulating conceptions of a general order of existence. His approach focuses on meaning, which makes it attractive to interpretivists.

Why the choice matters

A researcher using a substantive definition may conclude that religion is declining because fewer people believe in God; a researcher using a functional definition may find that “religion” has moved into new forms. When you evaluate any claim in Section C, ask which definition it relies on.

Difficulties in measuring religious belief

Three dimensions that do not always line up

Dimension Measured by Problem
Belief Survey questions on God, afterlife, prayer Wording changes answers; belief can be vague
Belonging Membership, census identity People may identify culturally without believing
Practice Attendance counts, prayer, ritual Practice may reflect social pressure, not belief

Grace Davie’s Religion in Britain since 1945: Believing without Belonging (1994) showed that these dimensions can separate: many people in Britain held some religious belief but did not belong to or attend a church. Measuring only attendance would understate belief; measuring only census identity might overstate it.

Specific measurement problems

  • Census questions. The census in England and Wales first asked a voluntary question on religion in 2001. Because the question asked about religious identity, it measured belonging rather than belief or practice.
  • Over-reporting. C. Kirk Hadaway, Penny Long Marler and Mark Chaves (1993) compared Americans’ self-reported church attendance with counts of people actually present in churches and found that self-reports substantially exaggerated attendance. Social desirability shapes answers in societies where religion is valued.
  • Under-reporting may occur where religion is stigmatised or politically risky.
  • Attendance counts. Head counts, such as the English Church Census conducted by Peter Brierley, are reliable for a given day but miss irregular attenders and those who worship at home.
  • Cross-cultural comparison. Congregational attendance is central to some faiths but not to others; in many Hindu households worship takes place at a home shrine, so attendance measures based on Christian practice can be misleading.
  • Operationalisation. Glock and Stark’s dimensions (belief, practice, experience, knowledge, consequences) show that “religiosity” has several parts, each needing its own indicator.

Methodological link: positivists prefer large surveys and counts for reliability; interpretivists argue that the meaning of belief can only be understood through in-depth interviews or observation.

Social groups and religiosity

Gender

  • Socialisation and roles: women’s greater involvement in caring and child-rearing may connect them with religious organisations and rites of passage.
  • Risk aversion: Alan Miller and John Hoffmann (1995) argued that women are more risk-averse than men and that not being religious can be seen as a risk.
  • Structural location: women’s greater presence in part-time work or at home has given more time and opportunity for religious involvement in some societies.
  • Evaluation: patterns differ between faiths and societies; in some religions men’s participation in public worship is higher because of religious rules.

Age

  • Ageing effect: people may become more religious as they approach death.
  • Generational effect: David Voas and Alasdair Crockett (2005) analysed British survey data and argued that each generation has been less religious than the one before, so decline is driven by generational replacement rather than individuals losing faith.
  • Exceptions: young people may be drawn to new religious movements or to forms of spirituality outside churches.

Ethnicity

  • Minority ethnic and migrant groups often show higher religiosity than majority populations in Western societies.
  • Cultural defence and transition (Bruce) explain this through identity and support in a new society.
  • Community: religious organisations may provide social networks, welfare and language support.
  • Evaluation: “ethnic minority” covers groups with very different religious traditions, and second and third generations may differ from their parents.

Class

  • Rodney Stark and William Sims Bainbridge (A Theory of Religion, 1987) argued that religion offers compensators, promises of future rewards, to those who lack rewards now, which helps explain the appeal of some sects to deprived groups.
  • Middle-class groups may be drawn to world-affirming movements and, in some societies, have higher rates of formal membership and attendance.
  • Evaluation: class patterns vary greatly by country and denomination.

Religion and other belief systems

The syllabus asks how religion compares with other ways of understanding the world, such as science and political ideologies.

  • Open and closed belief systems. Karl Popper argued that science is an open belief system: its claims are open to falsification. Religious belief systems are often described as closed, because they claim absolute truth and can explain away contradictions.
  • Self-sustaining beliefs. E.E. Evans-Pritchard’s Witchcraft, Oracles and Magic among the Azande (1937) showed how the Azande explained failures of their poison oracle without abandoning belief in it, for example by blaming incorrect procedure. Michael Polanyi argued that all belief systems, science included, have similar protective devices.
  • Comparing traditional thought and science. Robin Horton (1967) argued that African traditional religious thought and Western science both try to explain and predict events, but science is more open to alternative theories.
  • Ideologies as functional alternatives. Political ideologies such as Marxism or nationalism can provide meaning, ritual and community in ways similar to religion, which supports functional definitions.

Evaluation: sociologists of science, following Thomas Kuhn’s The Structure of Scientific Revolutions (1962), argue that scientists also work within paradigms that resist challenge, so the open/closed distinction may be one of degree.

Annotated model paragraph

Question focus: evaluate the view that religious belief cannot be measured accurately.

Davie’s idea of “believing without belonging” (1994) supports the view, because measures of membership and attendance miss people who hold private beliefs. [AO1 and AO2] Self-report surveys have their own problem: Hadaway, Marler and Chaves (1993) found that Americans’ reported attendance substantially exceeded actual counts. [AO3: evidence] However, combining attendance counts, surveys and in-depth interviews allows researchers to measure different dimensions separately, which improves validity. [AO3: counter-argument] Belief cannot be measured perfectly, but triangulation makes reasonably accurate measurement of specific dimensions possible. [AO3: judgement]

Common mistakes

  • Giving one definition of religion without saying how definitions affect findings.
  • Treating belief, belonging and practice as the same thing.
  • Explaining gender or age differences without evaluating them for particular faiths or societies.
  • Leaving out “religion and other belief systems”, which the syllabus names.
  • Quoting attendance or census figures you cannot source.

Exam technique

  • Explain questions: give the definition, measurement problem or explanation, develop it with a study, and apply it to an example.
  • Evaluate questions: contrast structural explanations (socialisation, structural location, deprivation) with interactionist ones (meaning, identity), as heading 11 asks.
  • Link forward to 12.1: every secularisation argument depends on how religion is defined and measured.

Get free revision emails (optional)

Occasional emails with practice questions, worked explanations and links to free resources for the qualification and subjects you choose. No spam, and you can unsubscribe from any email. The free tools on this site never need an email.

Subjects (optional, up to 6)

Choose a qualification to see its subjects.

Related resources

Related articles

Studying this with a teacher

Working through Sociology A LEVEL?

This page is free and stays free. If you would rather be taught it, Marlbridge runs Sociology classes one-to-one and in small groups of up to 15, online in your own time zone. The first trial class is free. WhatsApp replies within an hour (8am–11pm Pakistan time, every day); email the same day.

Cambridge Sociology teachers at Marlbridge