Skip to content
Marlbridge

Revision Notes

Cambridge A-Level Sociology (9699): Religion as a Source of Social Change – Revision Notes

Condensed 9699 notes on section 11.3: Weber's six steps, Tawney, Kautsky and Marshall, liberation theology, and the US Evangelical and Iranian case studies.

Subject
Sociology
Level
A LEVEL
Topic
Paper 4 – Globalisation, Media and Religion
Updated

Aligned to Cambridge A Level Sociology (9699), 2024-2026. Official specification .

Syllabus page (what it covers and how it is assessed): Cambridge A Level Sociology.

Syllabus points this page covers

9699 (A Level)

  • 11.3 Religion as a source of social change

Found an error? Report a correction.

Need help with this topic? Request a free trial class for A Level Sociology (9699).

These notes cover section 11.3 Religion as a source of social change of Cambridge International A Level Sociology (9699) Paper 4. Full explanations are in the religion and social change study guide; exam-style questions are in the religion and social change practice questions.

The argument in one paragraph

Weber argued that the Calvinist ethic, through salvation anxiety, the calling and asceticism, had an elective affinity with the spirit of capitalism and helped modern capitalism emerge. Critics argue that economic change came first (Tawney, Kautsky) or that religion was not sufficient (Marshall). Liberation theology shows religion opposing an unjust order, and religious movements in the USA and Iran show religion shaping political struggles, from gradual legal change to revolution. Religion can drive change, but usually alongside economic and political conditions.

Key terms

Term Meaning
Predestination God has already decided who will be saved
The elect Those chosen for salvation
Salvation anxiety Psychological strain of not knowing whether one is saved
The calling Worldly work as a duty to God
Asceticism Self-discipline and rejection of luxury
Spirit of capitalism Rational, disciplined pursuit of profit for reinvestment
Elective affinity A fit between ideas and interests that reinforce each other (Weber)
Verstehen Interpretive understanding of actors’ meanings
Iron cage Rational economic order that traps modern people
Liberation theology Catholic movement linking faith to the struggle against poverty and oppression
Preferential option for the poor Liberation theology’s commitment to put the poor first
Base ecclesial communities Small groups of poor Catholics relating the Bible to their conditions
Velayat-e faqih Guardianship of the Islamic jurist: clerical political authority (Khomeini)

Weber in six steps

  1. Predestination.
  2. Salvation anxiety.
  3. The calling: success as a possible sign of election.
  4. Asceticism: profits reinvested, not spent.
  5. Spirit of capitalism: Franklin’s “time is money”.
  6. Elective affinity with economic conditions, not sole cause.

Comparative studies: China and India had resources but lacked an ethic of rational worldly activity.

Iron cage: capitalism no longer needs its religious roots, linking to secularisation.

Alternative views

View Argument
Tawney (1926) Economic change came first; Protestantism adapted
Kautsky (Marxist) Capitalism predated Calvinism; capitalists were drawn to it
Counter-examples Early capitalism in some Catholic regions; slow development in some Calvinist areas
Marshall (1980) Scotland had the ethic but lacked capital and skilled labour
Martin (1990) Latin American Pentecostalism encourages discipline and saving, a modern parallel

Liberation theology

  • Origins: Vatican II (1962–65); Medellín (1968); base ecclesial communities; Gutiérrez (1971).
  • Significance: religion opposing injustice; challenges Marx; Löwy (1996) on a movement combining Christian and Marxist ideas; Maduro’s relative autonomy.
  • Limits: Vatican criticism from the 1980s; conservative appointments; democratisation; growth of Pentecostalism.

Case studies

Evangelicals in US politics

  • Moral Majority (1979); Christian Coalition (Pat Robertson, 1989).
  • Issues: abortion, school prayer, family values.
  • Roe v. Wade (1973) overturned by Dobbs (2022) after decades of campaigning.
  • Bruce (2003): limited success in a pluralist system — Dobbs invites re-evaluation.

Iran

  • White Revolution (1963): rapid modernisation and Westernisation.
  • Khomeini’s velayat-e faqih.
  • Protests 1978; Shah leaves January 1979; Khomeini returns February 1979; referendum creates the Islamic Republic in 1979.
  • Religion supplied leadership, mosque networks and a language of justice.

Also usable: the US civil rights movement and the Southern Christian Leadership Conference (1957); the Catholic Church and Solidarity in Poland in the 1980s.

Essay plan in five steps

“Religion is a conservative force rather than a source of change.” Evaluate.

  1. Define both sides: conservative (functionalism, Marxism, 11.2) versus change.
  2. Weber: Calvinist ethic and the spirit of capitalism; note elective affinity.
  3. Alternatives: Tawney, Kautsky, Marshall weaken the causal claim.
  4. Change in action: liberation theology; Iran 1979; US Evangelicals and Dobbs.
  5. Judge: religion can cause change when economic and political conditions favour it, and is conservative when tied to ruling institutions.

Exam traps

  • Weber did not say Calvinism was the only cause.
  • Include alternative views for balance.
  • Say why liberation theology matters for theory, not just what it was.
  • The syllabus says “such as”: other case studies are acceptable, but know at least one in depth.
  • Get the Iranian dates in order.

Self-test

  1. What is predestination, and why did it cause salvation anxiety?
  2. How did the idea of the calling encourage capitalist behaviour?
  3. What did Weber mean by elective affinity?
  4. What did Weber’s studies of China and India suggest?
  5. What did Tawney argue?
  6. What was Kautsky’s criticism of Weber?
  7. What did Marshall’s study of Scotland find?
  8. Name two events that shaped the origins of liberation theology.
  9. Why does liberation theology challenge Marxist theory?
  10. Give two reasons for the decline of liberation theology.
  11. How does the Dobbs decision (2022) relate to Bruce’s view of the Evangelical movement?
  12. What was velayat-e faqih?

Answers

  1. The belief that God has already decided who will be saved; believers could not know if they were chosen, which created anxiety.
  2. Worldly work became a duty to God and success a possible sign of election, encouraging disciplined, methodical work.
  3. A fit between Calvinist ideas and the spirit of capitalism that reinforced each other, without religion being the sole cause.
  4. That they had the economic resources for capitalism but lacked a religious ethic of rational worldly activity.
  5. That economic change came first and Protestant ideas adapted to justify it.
  6. That capitalism predated Calvinism, and capitalists were attracted to Calvinism because it suited their interests.
  7. A Calvinist work ethic existed, but shortages of capital and skilled labour slowed capitalist development.
  8. Any two: the Second Vatican Council (1962–65); the Medellín conference (1968); Gutiérrez’s book (1971); base ecclesial communities.
  9. It shows religion opposing an unjust order instead of legitimating it.
  10. Any two: Vatican criticism; conservative bishops appointed; democratisation; growth of Pentecostalism.
  11. Bruce argued the movement had limited policy success; Dobbs shows a major long-term legal change, so his judgement can be questioned.
  12. Khomeini’s doctrine that a senior Islamic jurist should hold political authority.

Get free revision emails (optional)

Occasional emails with practice questions, worked explanations and links to free resources for the qualification and subjects you choose. No spam, and you can unsubscribe from any email. The free tools on this site never need an email.

Subjects (optional, up to 6)

Choose a qualification to see its subjects.

Related resources

Related articles

Studying this with a teacher

Working through Sociology A LEVEL?

This page is free and stays free. If you would rather be taught it, Marlbridge runs Sociology classes one-to-one and in small groups of up to 15, online in your own time zone. The first trial class is free. WhatsApp replies within an hour (8am–11pm Pakistan time, every day); email the same day.

Cambridge Sociology teachers at Marlbridge