Study Guides
Cambridge A-Level Sociology (9699): Theories of the Media and Influences on Media Content
Cambridge 9699 section 9.2 in depth: pluralism, Marxism and hegemony, news selection, postmodernism, censorship and media influence on politics.
- Subject
- Sociology
- Level
- A LEVEL
- Topic
- Paper 4 – Globalisation, Media and Religion
- Author
- Marlbridge Academic Team
- Updated
- Reviewed by
- Naqiya Yousaf (what this means)
Aligned to Cambridge A Level Sociology (9699), 2024-2026. Official specification .
Syllabus page (what it covers and how it is assessed): Cambridge A Level Sociology.
Syllabus points this page covers
9699 (A Level)
- 9.2 Theories of the media and influences on media content
Found an error? Report a correction.
Need help with this topic? Request a free trial class for A Level Sociology (9699).
Section 9.2 of Cambridge International A Level Sociology (9699), Theories of the media and influences on media content, is the most theory-heavy part of Paper 4’s Media section. The syllabus lists seven points: pluralist theories; Marxist and neo-Marxist theories; factors that influence the selection and presentation of news; the concepts of mass manipulation and hegemony as different ways of understanding the production of media content; the postmodernist contribution; censorship as a factor influencing content; and how the media may influence the political process, including agenda setting, opinion polls and news reporting.
The media ownership, control and the new media guide introduces each theory. This page compares them more closely and adds evidence for evaluation. Use it with the theories of the media revision notes and the theories of the media practice questions.
Pluralist theories in more depth
Pluralism treats the media as a market place of ideas. Its argument rests on four claims:
- Consumer sovereignty. Audiences choose; outlets that ignore their wishes lose readers, viewers and advertisers.
- Diversity of outlets. Many competing media represent many groups and opinions.
- Professional journalism. Journalists value accuracy and independence, and editors resist interference.
- Regulation and public service. Laws and public-service broadcasting protect balance. The BBC’s founding aim under John Reith, to “inform, educate and entertain”, is the classic statement of this ideal.
Pluralists therefore see the media as a mirror: content reflects what audiences want and what is happening in society.
Evaluation. Critics reply that ownership is concentrated, that audiences can only choose from what is offered, and that commercial pressure favours cheap, popular content over diversity. Pluralism is stronger as a description of public-service broadcasting than of commercial markets.
Marxist and neo-Marxist theories
The manipulative (instrumental) approach
Owners deliberately use the media to spread ideas that serve their class interests. Supporters cite proprietors who appoint sympathetic editors or intervene in editorial lines. Harold Evans, editor of The Times, resigned in 1982 after disputes with its owner Rupert Murdoch, and later described the conflict in Good Times, Bad Times (1983).
The political economy approach
Peter Golding and Graham Murdock argued that economic structure, not owners’ personal views, shapes content. Media firms must make profits, so they depend on advertising, cut costs and avoid content that might alienate advertisers or large audiences. The result is a narrow range of views without anyone giving orders. This approach sits between the manipulative and hegemonic models.
The hegemonic (neo-Marxist) approach
Following Antonio Gramsci, hegemony is the dominance of ruling-class ideas through consent rather than force. Journalists, often from similar social backgrounds, share assumptions that make certain views seem like common sense and others seem extreme. The Glasgow University Media Group’s Bad News (1976), More Bad News (1980) and Really Bad News (1982) found that television news on industrial disputes tended to give more weight to management’s account.
Mass manipulation versus hegemony
| Mass manipulation | Hegemony | |
|---|---|---|
| Source of bias | Owners’ deliberate intervention | Shared assumptions of journalists and editors |
| Mechanism | Direct control: hiring, firing, editorial instructions | Routine news values, sources and “common sense” |
| Audience | Passive, accepts the message | Consents, but can resist; hegemony must be constantly maintained |
| Key thinkers | Miliband; Herman and Chomsky’s propaganda model | Gramsci; Glasgow University Media Group; Stuart Hall |
| Weakness | Little direct evidence of owners’ orders in most newsrooms | Hard to prove what journalists take for granted |
The syllabus asks you to see these as different ways of understanding the production of content: one locates power in individuals, the other in culture and routine.
What influences the selection and presentation of news?
- News values. Galtung and Ruge’s list (1965) was updated by Tony Harcup and Deirdre O’Neill (2001, revised 2017), who added values such as celebrity, entertainment and, for online news, shareability.
- Gatekeeping. David Manning White’s “Mr Gates” study (1950) showed a wire editor rejecting stories partly on personal judgement.
- Primary definers. Stuart Hall and colleagues (Policing the Crisis, 1978) argued that journalists rely on powerful, accredited sources such as police and politicians, whose framing of an issue becomes the starting point for coverage.
- Churnalism. Nick Davies’ Flat Earth News (2008) argued that under time and budget pressure journalists recycle press releases and agency copy rather than investigate.
- Framing. Robert Entman (1993) described framing as selecting some aspects of reality and making them more salient, which suggests a particular definition of the problem, cause and remedy.
- Commercial pressures, owners and practical constraints (deadlines, budgets, location) also shape content.
The postmodernist contribution
Postmodernists argue that in media-saturated societies the distinction between reality and its representation breaks down. Jean Baudrillard’s The Gulf War Did Not Take Place (1991) argued that for Western audiences the 1991 Gulf War existed mainly as a televised spectacle of images and commentary. Audiences are fragmented, meanings multiply, and no single class or owner can impose a dominant ideology.
Contribution: explains fragmentation, the role of images and the active construction of meaning. Limitation: underplays the concentrated economic power of media corporations, which Marxists and political economists emphasise.
Censorship as an influence on content
| Type | Meaning | Example |
|---|---|---|
| State censorship | Government prevents publication | Blocking of foreign websites by China’s internet controls |
| Legal limits | Laws restrict what can be published | Defamation, privacy and official secrets laws |
| Voluntary systems | Advisory agreements with the state | The UK’s DSMA-Notice system on national security |
| Regulation | Standards enforced by regulators | Broadcast impartiality rules |
| Commercial censorship | Avoiding content that might offend advertisers | Dropping stories that criticise major advertisers |
| Self-censorship | Journalists anticipate owners’, advertisers’ or states’ reactions | Avoiding topics that risk legal action |
Censorship supports both Marxist views (protecting powerful interests) and pluralist ones (laws made by elected governments to protect individuals).
How the media may influence the political process
- Agenda setting — telling people what to think about, by choosing which issues to cover.
- Framing — telling people how to think about an issue by emphasising certain causes and solutions.
- Opinion polls — published polls can create a bandwagon effect (support for the party shown winning) or an underdog effect; they also shape coverage as a “horse race”.
- News reporting — partisan newspapers may support parties openly. After the UK general election of 1992, The Sun’s headline “It’s The Sun Wot Won It” claimed credit for the result, though researchers dispute how much the press actually changes votes.
- Social media — targeted advertising and the spread of misleading content.
Evaluation: media influence may be greater on undecided voters and on which issues are discussed than on settled loyalties; people also choose media that already match their views.
Annotated model paragraph
Question focus: evaluate the view that media content is shaped by owners.
The manipulative Marxist approach supports the view: Harold Evans’s resignation from The Times in 1982 after disputes with Murdoch suggests owners can intervene directly. [AO1 and AO2] However, Golding and Murdock argue that economic pressures such as dependence on advertising narrow content without any direct orders, so owners matter less as individuals than the market does. [AO3: alternative explanation] The Glasgow University Media Group adds that journalists’ shared assumptions produce bias by themselves, which suggests hegemony rather than manipulation. [AO3] Owners can shape content, but routine, commercial and cultural pressures explain most of it. [AO3: judgement]
Common mistakes
- Treating all Marxists as instrumentalists; distinguish manipulation, political economy and hegemony.
- Listing news values without saying how they shape which stories run and how.
- Confusing agenda setting (what to think about) with framing (how to think about it).
- Writing about postmodernism without saying what it contributes, which is the syllabus wording.
- Treating censorship as only state censorship.
Exam technique
- For evaluate questions on theory, set up a contrast (pluralism versus Marxism, or manipulation versus hegemony) and use evidence on news production to judge between them.
- For the political process bullet, separate the three named mechanisms: agenda setting, opinion polls and news reporting.
- Link back to 9.1: ownership trends are evidence for Marxist theories; audience choice and public-service broadcasting are evidence for pluralism.
Get free revision emails (optional)
Occasional emails with practice questions, worked explanations and links to free resources for the qualification and subjects you choose. No spam, and you can unsubscribe from any email. The free tools on this site never need an email.
Related resources
-
Practice questions
Cambridge A-Level Sociology (9699): Theories of the Media and Influences on Media Content – Practice Questions
Twelve original Cambridge 9699 questions on section 9.2: pluralism, Marxist approaches, news selection, censorship and media and politics, with answers.
Sociology · Cambridge · A Level
Try questions -
Revision notes
Cambridge A-Level Sociology (9699): Theories of the Media and Influences on Media Content – Revision Notes
Condensed 9699 notes on section 9.2: pluralism, three Marxist approaches, news selection, postmodernism, censorship and politics, with a self-test.
Sociology · Cambridge · A Level
Revise topic -
Study guides
Cambridge A-Level Sociology (9699): Traditional Media and the New Media
Cambridge 9699 section 9.1 in depth: integration and convergence, conglomerates and platforms, who controls the media, and whether new media undermine old.
Sociology · Cambridge · A Level
Read guide
Related articles
-
teaching
Sociology tuition online: GCSE, IGCSE, O Level and A Level
Which Sociology specifications Marlbridge teaches live online, how the papers are set out, where students usually lose marks, and how a trial class works.
9 October 2026
-
teaching
A Level tuition in Dubai: Cambridge or Pearson Edexcel International A Level?
Schools in Dubai and Abu Dhabi teach either Cambridge International AS & A Level or Pearson Edexcel International A Level. How the two are structured, why it matters for tuition, and how online classes from Lahore work.
9 October 2026
Studying this with a teacher
Working through Sociology A LEVEL?
This page is free and stays free. If you would rather be taught it, Marlbridge runs Sociology classes one-to-one and in small groups of up to 15, online in your own time zone. The first trial class is free. WhatsApp replies within an hour (8am–11pm Pakistan time, every day); email the same day.
Cambridge Sociology teachers at Marlbridge