Skip to content
Marlbridge

Study Guides

Edexcel International A Level Law (YLA1): The Criminal Offender

A deep dive into YLA1 section 2.2 The criminal offender: actus reus, mens rea, strict liability, property offences, duress, intoxication and sentencing.

Subject
Law
Level
A LEVELS
Topic
Paper 2 – The Law in Action
Updated

Aligned to Pearson Edexcel A Level Law (YLA1), Issue 4, November 2021. Official specification .

Syllabus page (what it covers and how it is assessed): Pearson Edexcel A Level Law.

Syllabus points this page covers

YLA1

  • 2.2 The criminal offender

Found an error? Report a correction.

Need help with this topic? Request a free trial class for A Level Law (YLA1).

This guide covers section 2.2, The criminal offender, the second of the three sections of Paper 2 (The Law in Action) in Pearson Edexcel International Advanced Level Law, Issue 4. The Law in Action guide lists each offence and its section. This page adds the cases that define the elements and shows how to work through a criminal scenario.

What section 2.2 covers

  • The nature of criminal liability (2.2.1 to 2.2.3): actus reus (causation, omissions), mens rea (intention including transferred malice, subjective recklessness) and strict liability. The specification notes that ss 18, 20 and 47 of the Offences Against the Person Act 1861 may be used to illustrate these ideas.
  • Property offences (2.2.4 to 2.2.7): theft, robbery, burglary and blackmail (Theft Act 1968); fraud by false representation and obtaining services dishonestly (Fraud Act 2006); making off without payment (Theft Act 1978); criminal damage and lawful excuse (Criminal Damage Act 1971).
  • General defences (2.2.8 to 2.2.9): duress of threats and of circumstances; voluntary and involuntary intoxication.
  • Sentencing (2.2.10): custodial sentences, community orders, fines and discharges under the Criminal Justice Act 2003.

Actus reus: causation

Factual causation asks whether the result would have happened “but for” the defendant’s act. In R v White [1910] the victim died of a heart attack before the poison could work, so White was not the cause of death (he was guilty of attempted murder). Legal causation asks whether the act was an operating and substantial cause (R v Smith [1959]). The chain can be broken by an intervening act, but:

  • the defendant must take the victim as they find them (the thin skull rule: R v Blaue [1975]);
  • poor medical treatment rarely breaks the chain unless it is “palpably wrong” (R v Jordan [1956]) or so independent that the original wound is insignificant (R v Cheshire [1991]);
  • a victim’s reasonably foreseeable reaction in escaping does not break it (R v Roberts [1971]).

Actus reus: omissions

There is no general duty to act, but a duty arises from:

Source Case
Contract R v Pittwood [1902]: a level-crossing keeper who left the gate open
Relationship R v Gibbins and Proctor [1918]: a father who starved his child
Voluntary assumption of care R v Stone and Dobinson [1977]
Public office R v Dytham [1979]: a police officer who did nothing during an assault
Creating a dangerous situation R v Miller [1983]: failing to deal with a fire he had started
Statute For example, failing to provide a breath specimen

Mens rea

  • Direct intention: the defendant’s aim or purpose (R v Mohan [1975]).
  • Oblique intention: the jury may find intention where the result was a virtual certainty and the defendant appreciated that (R v Woollin [1998], refining R v Nedrick [1986]).
  • Subjective recklessness: the defendant personally foresaw a risk and unreasonably took it (R v Cunningham [1957]; for criminal damage, R v G [2003]).
  • Transferred malice: mens rea towards one victim transfers to another (R v Latimer [1886]), but not between different kinds of offence (R v Pembliton [1874]: intending to hit people, he broke a window).
  • Coincidence: actus reus and mens rea must coincide, though a continuing act can satisfy this (Fagan v Metropolitan Police Commissioner [1969]).

Using the OAPA 1861: s 47 (assault occasioning actual bodily harm) needs only mens rea for the assault; s 20 (unlawful wounding or inflicting grievous bodily harm) needs foresight of some harm; s 18 (wounding or causing grievous bodily harm with intent) needs intention. These show how mens rea separates offences with similar actus reus.

Strict liability

Some offences need no mens rea for at least one element, mostly regulatory offences protecting the public. The presumption is that mens rea is required (Sweet v Parsley [1970]), displaced only where the statute and its purpose show otherwise (Gammon v Attorney General of Hong Kong [1985]). Examples: selling unfit meat despite taking care (Callow v Tillstone [1900]) and selling a lottery ticket to an under-age buyer (Harrow LBC v Shah [1999]). For: efficient enforcement and higher standards. Against: an offender who took every care can be convicted.

Property offences

Theft (Theft Act 1968, ss 1 to 6): dishonestly appropriating property belonging to another with the intention of permanently depriving the other of it.

Element Section Key point
Dishonesty s 2 Not dishonest if D believes they have a legal right, the owner would consent, or the owner cannot be found by reasonable steps. Otherwise the test in Ivey v Genting Casinos [2017]: D’s actual belief about the facts, then the standards of ordinary decent people
Appropriation s 3 Any assumption of the rights of an owner (R v Morris [1983]), even with consent (R v Gomez [1993])
Property s 4 Money and all other property, real or personal, including things in action
Belonging to another s 5 Includes possession or control; property got by another’s mistake (s 5(4))
Intention permanently to deprive s 6 Includes treating the thing as one’s own to dispose of; borrowing is enough only if the “goodness” is gone (R v Lloyd [1985])

The specification states candidates are not examined on a change in the law until two years after it, giving Ivey as its own example, so it is now part of the law you should know.

Robbery (s 8): stealing, and immediately before or at the time of doing so, using force or putting someone in fear of force, in order to steal. Little force is needed (R v Dawson and James [1976]); appropriation can be continuing (R v Hale [1978]); no theft means no robbery (R v Robinson [1977]).

Burglary (s 9): s 9(1)(a) entering a building or part of a building as a trespasser with intent to steal, inflict grievous bodily harm or do unlawful damage; s 9(1)(b) having entered as a trespasser, stealing or inflicting grievous bodily harm, or attempting to. Entry must be “effective and substantial” (R v Collins [1972]), later put simply as “effective” (R v Brown [1985]), and can be partial (R v Ryan [1996]); “part of a building” covers a restricted area such as behind a shop counter (R v Walkington [1979]).

Blackmail (s 21; s 34 defines gain and loss): an unwarranted demand with menaces, with a view to gain or intent to cause loss, gain and loss being in money or other property.

Fraud Act 2006: s 2 fraud by false representation (dishonestly making a false representation, intending to make a gain or cause a loss); s 5 defines gain and loss; s 11 obtaining services dishonestly, knowing payment is required and intending not to pay.

Making off without payment (Theft Act 1978, s 3): knowing that payment on the spot is required, dishonestly making off without paying, intending to avoid payment permanently (R v Allen [1985]).

Criminal damage (1971 Act, s 1): destroying or damaging property belonging to another, intending or being reckless as to that. Lawful excuse (s 5): an honest belief that the owner would consent, or that the property needed protecting from immediate danger; the belief need only be honest (Jaggard v Dickinson [1981]).

General defences

Duress of threats: a threat of death or serious injury; the R v Graham [1982] two-stage test (was D compelled by a reasonable belief in the threat, and would a sober person of reasonable firmness have responded the same way?); not available to murder (R v Howe [1987]) or attempted murder (R v Gotts [1992]); lost where D voluntarily associated with criminals (R v Hasan [2005]). Duress of circumstances applies the same test to danger from a situation (R v Willer [1986]; R v Martin [1989]).

Intoxication: voluntary intoxication is no defence to basic-intent offences (DPP v Majewski [1977]) but can negate specific intent; “Dutch courage” defeats it (Attorney General for Northern Ireland v Gallagher [1963]). Involuntary intoxication helps only if D did not form mens rea: an intoxicated intent is still intent (R v Kingston [1994]); taking a sedative that has an unexpected effect may count (R v Hardie [1985]).

Sentencing

The Criminal Justice Act 2003 framework, now consolidated in the Sentencing Act 2020, sets four main types:

  • Custody: only where the offence is so serious that neither a fine nor a community sentence can be justified; may be suspended.
  • Community orders: one or more requirements, such as unpaid work, curfew or rehabilitation activity.
  • Fines: set by the seriousness of the offence and the offender’s means.
  • Discharges: conditional or absolute.

Courts consider seriousness (culpability and harm), aggravating factors (previous convictions; hostility based on race or religion), mitigating factors, and a reduction of up to one third for an early guilty plea.

Worked example: a burglary scenario

Owen enters a neighbour’s garage through an unlocked door, meaning to take a bicycle. He finds the owner inside and pushes her over to get away, without taking anything.

  1. Trespasser? He had no permission: yes.
  2. Building or part of one? A garage is a building.
  3. Intent on entry? He intended to steal: s 9(1)(a) burglary is complete on entry.
  4. Robbery? No theft occurred, so no robbery (Robinson); consider an assault offence for the push.

Common mistakes

  • Using “but for” without legal causation.
  • Calling borrowing theft without applying s 6 and Lloyd.
  • Mixing up s 9(1)(a) (intent at entry) with s 9(1)(b) (an offence after entry).
  • Allowing duress as a defence to murder.
  • Naming a sentence without explaining what it involves.

Exam technique

For scenarios, deal with one offence at a time: actus reus, mens rea, defences, then conclusion. Explain needs the rule plus a case; evaluate or assess needs strengths, weaknesses and a judgement.

Next steps

Condense with the criminal offender revision notes and practise with the criminal offender practice questions.

Get free revision emails (optional)

Occasional emails with practice questions, worked explanations and links to free resources for the qualification and subjects you choose. No spam, and you can unsubscribe from any email. The free tools on this site never need an email.

Subjects (optional, up to 6)

Choose a qualification to see its subjects.

Related resources

Related articles

Studying this with a teacher

Working through Law A LEVELS?

This page is free and stays free. If you would rather be taught it, Marlbridge runs Law classes one-to-one and in small groups of up to 15, online in your own time zone. The first trial class is free. WhatsApp replies within an hour (8am–11pm Pakistan time, every day); email the same day.

Pearson Edexcel Law teachers at Marlbridge