Skip to content
Marlbridge

Revision Notes

Edexcel International A Level Law (YLA1): The Nature, Purpose of and Liability in Law – Revision Notes

Condensed recall notes on YLA1 section 1.1: rules and law, civil and criminal liability, the seven theories of punishment, legal theory and law and morality.

Subject
Law
Level
A LEVELS
Topic
Paper 1 – Underlying Principles of Law and the English Legal System
Updated

Aligned to Pearson Edexcel A Level Law (YLA1), Issue 4, November 2021. Official specification .

Syllabus page (what it covers and how it is assessed): Pearson Edexcel A Level Law.

Syllabus points this page covers

YLA1

  • 1.1 The nature, purpose of and liability in law

Found an error? Report a correction.

Need help with this topic? Request a free trial class for A Level Law (YLA1).

Condensed for the final weeks. For the full explanation, use the nature, purpose of and liability in law study guide.

Rules and law (1.1.1 to 1.1.3)

A legal rule has certainty (a recognised source), enforcement (courts, police, prosecutors) and a state sanction. A school rule or rule of etiquette may have the first two in a weak form but never the third.

  • Rights, duties, privileges, liabilities: what the law allows, requires, protects and penalises.
  • Natural person = a human being. Legal person = a company or other body with its own legal identity (Salomon v A Salomon & Co Ltd [1897]).
Civil Criminal
Parties Claimant v defendant Prosecution (R) v defendant
Burden Claimant Prosecution (Woolmington v DPP [1935])
Standard Balance of probabilities Beyond reasonable doubt
Result Liable Guilty
Outcome Remedy: damages, injunction Sanction: custody, community order, fine, discharge

One event, two cases: a driver who injures a cyclist can be prosecuted for a driving offence and sued in negligence. Different parties, courts and standards, so an acquittal does not block the civil claim.

Theories of punishment (1.1.8)

Learn all seven, each with a sentence link:

  1. Revenge: society hitting back; behind calls for long sentences.
  2. Retribution: just deserts, proportionate; sentences scaled to seriousness.
  3. Denunciation: public condemnation; exemplary sentences.
  4. Deterrence: individual and general; custody, suspended sentences.
  5. Rehabilitation: reform; community orders with treatment or supervision.
  6. Reparation: amends; compensation orders, unpaid work.
  7. Restoration: repair the offender–victim relationship; restorative justice.

Criminal Justice Act 2003, s 142 purposes for adults: punishment, reduction of crime (including deterrence), reform and rehabilitation, protection of the public, reparation.

Theory Core claim Theorists
Positivism Law is valid if made by the right authority and procedure, whatever its morality Austin (command backed by sanction), Hart (primary and secondary rules, rule of recognition)
Natural law A higher moral law; an unjust law is not truly law Aquinas; Fuller (inner morality of law)
Utilitarianism The right law gives the greatest happiness of the greatest number Bentham, Mill (harm principle)

Law and morality (1.1.12 to 1.1.14)

  • Wolfenden Report (1957): private consensual homosexual acts between adults should not be criminal; private morality is “not the law’s business”.
  • Devlin: shared morality holds society together, so law may enforce it.
  • Hart: only harm to others justifies intervention (following Mill).
  • Public morality = society’s shared code. Private morality = individual conduct not harming others.

Cases: Shaw v DPP [1962] and R v Brown [1993] enforce morality; R v Wilson [1996] respects private choice; R v R [1991] and Gillick [1985] show law moving with attitudes; Airedale NHS Trust v Bland [1993] and Re A (Conjoined Twins) [2000] show courts facing life-and-death moral questions.

Key terms

Term Meaning
Liability Legal responsibility for a wrong, leading to a remedy or sanction
Remedy What a civil court orders to put right a wrong
Sanction A penalty imposed by a criminal court
Legal personality Capacity to hold rights and duties
General deterrence Discouraging others by example
Rule of recognition Hart’s test for identifying valid law
Harm principle Mill’s idea that the state may only restrain conduct harming others

Exam traps

  • “Prosecutor” in a civil case, or “liable” in a criminal one.
  • A theory of punishment with no sentence attached.
  • Legal theories with no named theorist.
  • Hart/Devlin retold without applying it to a case.

Self-test

  1. State the three features that make a rule a legal rule.
  2. Give the standard of proof in civil and in criminal cases.
  3. Which case confirms the prosecution bears the burden of proof?
  4. Link reparation and rehabilitation each to a sentence.
  5. What did Hart mean by a rule of recognition?
  6. What did the Wolfenden Report recommend?
  7. Why is R v Wilson contrasted with R v Brown?

Answers: 1. Certainty, enforcement and sanction by the state. 2. Civil: balance of probabilities; criminal: beyond reasonable doubt. 3. Woolmington v DPP [1935]. 4. Reparation: a compensation order or unpaid work; rehabilitation: a community order with a drug rehabilitation or supervision requirement. 5. The test, accepted by officials, used to identify which rules are valid law. 6. That homosexual acts in private between consenting adults should no longer be criminal, because private morality is not the law’s business. 7. In Brown consent was no defence to harm inflicted in private sadomasochistic activity; in Wilson a wife’s consent to branding by her husband was effective, so the courts treated a private act between spouses differently.

Get free revision emails (optional)

Occasional emails with practice questions, worked explanations and links to free resources for the qualification and subjects you choose. No spam, and you can unsubscribe from any email. The free tools on this site never need an email.

Subjects (optional, up to 6)

Choose a qualification to see its subjects.

Related resources

Related articles

Studying this with a teacher

Working through Law A LEVELS?

This page is free and stays free. If you would rather be taught it, Marlbridge runs Law classes one-to-one and in small groups of up to 15, online in your own time zone. The first trial class is free. WhatsApp replies within an hour (8am–11pm Pakistan time, every day); email the same day.

Pearson Edexcel Law teachers at Marlbridge